If you say a bad word on the airwaves, the FCC wants the broadcaster to pay a half-million-dollar fine. That idea really appeals to Jaime Masada, a comedy-club owner who suddenly fancies himself a brave fighter against racial insensitivity.
You see, the latest on the Michael Richards kerfuffle is that Mr. Masada, the proprietor of the Laugh Factory, the L.A. club where Richards had his horrible racist meltdown, has joined the chorus of those demanding further atonement. He also wants out-of-line comedians to pay millions of dollars' worth of fines.
Jaime Masada extended an invitation to Richards to perform on December 4 at the club to apologize to the guests who attended the November 17 performance. ... Masada suggested Richards donate at least $500,000 to charity for every time he unleashed the derogatory term. Masada also said the comedy club will ban comedians from using all "hateful words" including the "n-word." "We want to be the first place in the world to ask all of the comedians if they go on stage and use the 'n-word,' (it) comes out of their paycheck," Masada said.
It's a little bit like the Muslims and the Pope, isn't it? No matter how many times the Vatican apologizes for his perceived insult to Islam of a few months ago, his original words, for those who are high on their own righteousness, are the gift that keeps on giving. Multiple apologies are not enough; the perpetrator must continue his public self-flagellation and self-recrimination until the eagerly displayed moral outrage of his accusers either dissipates or finds a new lightning rod.
Mr. Masada can implement any policy he sees fit — it's his club. I'll just note that his plan to ban "hateful words" seems a little opportunistic. I mean, why now? Because this particular bandwagon was too enticing to ignore? If Mr. Masada is so bothered by words that offend, might he be in the wrong business? And why didn't he ban those terms from his club years ago?
Also, whose sensibilities deserve protection from which words? And which word carries what penalty, exactly? If instances of 'nigger' draw $500,000 each, shall we punish 'raghead,' 'goatfucker,' 'spic,' and 'hymie' with, say, $250,000? And 'cracker,' 'bull-dyke' and 'faggot' with $100,000, maybe? Does that sound about right? Send your suggestions to Mr. Masada, as I'm sure he's struggling with these weighty questions.
Maybe you could also tell him whether you think there should be an exemption for black comedians, like Chris Rock, who love using the n-word. Chris Rock, of course, has performed at Mr. Masada's club, presumably with a free pass to utter any potentially hateful word of his choosing. So, do different standards apply to black funnymen? Does Mr. Masada advocate comedy apartheid? As Earl Ofari Hutchinson writes,
[B]lack comedians and rappers ... have virtually canonized the word. They sprinkle the word throughout their rap lyrics and comedy lines, and black writers, and filmmakers go through lengthy gyrations to justify using the word. During a panel discussion at the Summer Television Critics Association tour in 2005, Aaron McGruder, creator of the popular comic strip Boondocks, defiantly told the audience that he'd use the n-word as much as he pleased in his comic strip and in his series on the Cartoon Network's Adult Swim. If folks didn't like it, well tough.
McGruder and Rock, like Richards, are subject to simple-to-grasp market forces. People are free to see their shows or to avoid them. We surely don't need the FCC to tell us which fare is permissible and which deserves huge fines; just as we don't need comedy-club owners to go down that same censorious path.
No one has punished Michael Richards more than Michael Richards. His obscene tirade virtually assured the end of his career. He has since obediently prostrated himself and asked for forgiveness. To pile on and demand that he do it again and again is almost as unseemly as the behavior that provoked those calls in the first place. And telling other comedians that their use of bad words now carries heavy fines is about as offensive as anything they might find themselves spewing.
Lay off.
Recent Comments