Christian Emily Mapfuwa, of Brentwood, Essex, said the show, entitled Gone, Yet Still, was offensive to her faith and instructed her lawyers to seek a private prosecution against the gallery. She argued the Baltic would not have dared depict Mohammed in such a way.
I think Ms. Mapfuwa is on to something there. The reason why Mohammed's erect member is unlikely to be depicted is well-known to all. The widespread reticence has nothing to do with respect and everything to do with sure-fire threats of violence as well as, sometimes, actual smashings, slashings, and murders. How wonderfully christian that the Lord's followers now threaten to take a page from the Mohammedans' bloody playbook.
So there is supposedly a witness who felt like destroying the statue, and lo, someone with the benefit of an actual law degree argues that the existence of such would-be vandals is the very reason why impolite religious images must be outlawed across the land. Incredible.
The actual law, with which solicitor Michael Phillips surely is at least somewhat acquainted, goes the other way: Destroy someone else's property, prepare to go to jail.
Over at mediawatchwatch UK, blogger 'Monitor' predicts that the case will have a life-long special resonance for the plaintiff:


What always gets me laughing about these cases is that OBVIOUSLY, God is fully capable of destroying such offensive art - or the artist - on His/Her own (assuming that God exists, of course). So you could reason that if said art is NOT destroyed it cannot be so offensive (to God) as the critics claim it to be.
Oh, wait, there I go again expecting religious fanatics to be LOGICAL !
Posted by: Tom G | Thursday, November 13, 2008 at 12:25 PM
But did they show why Christ had a hardon? I doubt it. Apparently a couple of the apostles were pretty buff.
Posted by: hermesten | Friday, November 14, 2008 at 11:02 PM
So someone "felt like smashing the object." So what? Maybe that's the emotional reaction the artist intended to evoke. That reveals a problem with the viewer, not with the artist.
One thing you have to keep in mind is that whenever you say something meaningful, you will tick off a bunch of people. The more meaningful, the more people you'll tick off. Making a difference is about polarizing your audience, not bringing them together. Funny, Jesus Christ said something like that himself.
-TimK
Posted by: Tim King | Monday, November 17, 2008 at 10:13 AM